Home » We all try to add value

  • fortem-diamond

    We all try to add value


Kevin Gray
Chief Investment Officer

5 min read

We all try to add value

We all try to add value

‘Strive not to be a success, but rather to be of value.’ – Albert Einstein

‘You can’t predict, you can prepare.’ – Howard Marks

‘Never confuse genius with a bull market.’ – Anon

‘People have a deep distrust of machines. Have you seen Terminator? Or 2? Or 3? Or 4?’ – Owen Wilson as Nick Campbell, The Internship

The debate around value and growth investing is one that will be very familiar to readers; value has gone through a notorious and prolonged period of significant underperformance.

May saw a value (cheap stocks versus their fundamentals) revival compared with growth (stocks with rising earnings), after lagging for over a decade. This led to a multitude of commentaries suggesting that, after numerous false dawns, an inflection point for value had finally arrived; Messrs Buffet and Ackman were poised to claim victory…

Source: Bloomberg

A month on and value investing, and indeed Buffet himself, are being questioned possibly more than ever before, being outperformed by a guy picking scrabble tiles from a bag at random. May and early June’s sizeable value rally has faded and retraced much of its progress, hile growth has continued to defy gravity.

That more growth-oriented view can be expressed simply by buying the index in the US currently. The current weighting to Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, Alphabet and Facebook is over 20% of the S&P 500 so, by owning the index, one is automatically taking a very growth- riented view.

How much those tech behemoths are currently driving the index is also giving some investors cause for concern, especially given the scope for increased regulatory burdens moving forward and how much further the sector potentially has to fall from its heady valuations:

Source: Bloomberg

There is also a large and growing school who believe that when value does finally start to show itself, it is likely to be an extremely profitable trade; the question is when. Currently, expressing that view in the form of long only equity, in place of a more growth-oriented allocation such as an S&P 500 tracker, is a risk in itself.

For those investors looking at fundamentals (the clowns!), for years the mega-cap growth companies in the S&P 500 (FAAMG) have provided the growth that was lacking in the economy as a whole, and while growth has been hard to come by, investors have been happy to pay a heavy premium for it:

Look familiar?

Source: Bloomberg

However, whether one is predicting a significant recovery in activity from here, or growth to remain muted/negative may be irrelevant to the fate of those tech stocks in the near term; a pick up in growth would likely lower the premium applied to those companies’ future growth prospects (when growth is less scarce, investors will pay less for it), while markets coming back to fundamentals would likely hit them hardest with their stratospheric valuations and discretionary nature.

S&P 500 Equal Weight Index

Here at Fortem Capital, we constantly look for ways to bridge the ‘normal’ investment world with that of our derivative world. A rather neat way one might look to edge value into a portfolio, without completely forgoing those tech behemoths, would be to tweak the S&P 500 as an underlying within a typical structure. The S&P 500 is a growth index by virtue of its largest constituents being highly growth-oriented companies. However, by equally weighting the index constituents, one can express more of a value-tilted view. For example, exposure to those largest five companies, which is over 20% in an S&P 500 ETF, would be nearer 1% in an equally weighted index. Similarly, exposure to the smaller value names in the index would increase.

For an autocall, the equally weighted index also gives a pick-up on the coupon. For a supertracker, added participation would potentially compensate for any continued underperformance of value versus long-only S&P 500 market cap weighted exposure. With both shapes, one also gains the benefit of some conditional capital protection not afforded to those owning long-only equity.

There are few certainties in life; death, taxes, and the debates around active vs passive and value vs growth continuing to rage. It is likely too early to hang one’s hat completely on either side, but the time to start edging into value may be drawing near.

– This document has been issued and approved as a financial promotion by Fortem Capital Limited for the purpose of section 21 of the Financial Services and Markets Acts 2000. Fortem Capital Limited registration number 10042702 is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under firm reference number 755370.
– This document is intended for Professional Investors, Institutional Clients and Advisors and should not be communicated to any other person.
– The information has been prepared solely for information purposes only and is not an offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell the product.
– Data is sourced from Fortem Capital Limited and external sources. The data is as at the date of this document and has been reviewed by Fortem Capital Limited.
– Information, including prices, analytical data and opinions contained within this document are believed to be correct, accurate and derived from reliable sources as at the date of the document. However, no representation or warranty, expressed or implied is made as to the correctness, accuracy or validity of such information.
– Fortem Capital Limited assumes no responsibility or

liability for any errors, omissions or inaccuracy with respect to the information contained within this document.
– All price and analytical data included in this document is intended for indicative purposes only and is as at the date of the document.
– The information within this document does not take into account the specific investment objective or financial situation of any person. Investors should refer to the final documentation and any prospectus to ascertain all of the risks and terms associated with these securities and seek independent advice, where necessary, before making any decision to buy or sell.
– The product may not be offered, sold, transferred or delivered directly or indirectly in the United States to, or for the account or benefit of, any U.S. Person.
– The Fortem Capital Progressive Growth Fund is a Sub-Fund of Skyline, an open-ended investment company with variable capital incorporated on 1 June 2010 with limited liability under the laws of Ireland with segregated liability between Funds. The Company is authorised in Ireland by the Central Bank of Ireland pursuant to the UCITS Regulations.

SWITZERLAND – The interests in the UCITS Fund and any related services, information and opinions described or referenced in this document are not, and may not be, offered or marketed to or directed at persons in Switzerland (a) that do not meet the definition of “qualified investor" pursuant to the Swiss Federal Act on Collective Investment Schemes of 23 June 2006 (“CISA") (“Non-Qualified Investors"), or (b) that are high net worth individuals (including private investment structures established for such high-net worth individuals if they do not have professional treasury operations) that have opted out of customer protection under the Swiss Federal Financial Services Act of 15 June 2018 (“FinSA") and that have elected to be treated as “professional clients" and “qualified investors" under the FinSA and the CISA, respectively (“Elective Qualified Investors").
In particular, none of the information provided in this document should be construed as an offer in Switzerland for the purchase or sale of the interests or any related services, nor as advertising in Switzerland for the interests or any related services, to or directed at Non-Qualified Investors or

Elective Qualified Investors. Circulating or otherwise providing access to this document or offering, advertising or selling the interests or any related services to Non-Qualified Investors or Elective Qualified Investors may trigger, in particular, approval requirements and other regulatory requirements in Switzerland.
This document does not constitute a prospectus pursuant to Articles 35 et seqq. FinSA and may not fulfill the information standards established thereunder. No key information document pursuant to Swiss law has been established for the interests. The interests will not be listed or admitted to trading on a Swiss trading venue and, consequently, the information presented in this document may not fulfill the information standards set out in the relevant trading venue rules."

For more information on the investment philosophy or any of Fortem’s investment offerings, please do not hesitate to contact the team, we would be delighted to hear from you